[Dixielandjazz] Solos and applause
Robert S. Ringwald
robert at ringwald.com
Sat Mar 26 19:30:01 PST 2005
Bill Gunter writes regarding Artie Shaw's comments on applause:
-> Picky picky picky ...
> Classical music isn't jazz . . . the conventions are different.
> Theoretically, one applauds at the conclusion of the symphony or concerto
> and not at the end of each movement or section. Only the unwashed do that
> but it's totally understandable . . . after all, the closing cadenza of
> the movement has been played and the music stops. Seems reasonable to
> applaud at that point. Matter of fact, I often feel rather stupid when,
> after a particularly great movement, I am just supposed to sit there mute
> and restrain my enthusiasm until the end of the last section. Of course, I
> silently pat myself on the back and am pleased with my superior tastes
> that I'm not one of those ignorant peasants who will applaud at anything.
> Is that dumb or what!!!
Bob Ringwald responds:
Sometimes I have such a good movement that I feel it deserves applause.
However, perhaps this is not the time & place to discuss this phenomenon?
> Shaw was a rigid perfectionist and jazz is loose and really invites
> audience involvement. One doesn't need an "authority" to tell one how to
> respond to music . . . one just does!!!!! Sheesh!!!
> Furthermore - If you wanna see total audience participation, go to a local
> rock concert and watch how everyone sits quietly until the last drum blast
> and then listen as they applaud appreciatively and with dignity and
> restraint. Yeah, right.
> Respectfully submitted,
> Bill "Wow! Love that Scherzo!" Gunter
> jazzboard at hotmail.com
> Dixielandjazz mailing list
> Dixielandjazz at ml.islandnet.com
More information about the Dixielandjazz