[Dixielandjazz] Sacramento Passed Up?
marekboym at gmail.com
Thu Jun 7 05:46:57 PDT 2007
So do I, but do not tell anybody, in particular - not Steve...
On 06/06/07, Steve Barbone <barbonestreet at earthlink.net> wrote:
> As many know, I am a believer that "we" are to blame that OKOM is not more
> popular with the younger generations. And by "we" I mean "we". Here's an
> example, via a letter to the EDITOR. AMERICAN RAG, in the June Issue:
> SACRAMENTO PASSED UP.
> "A small group of which I am a member have attended each of the Sacramento
> Jazz affairs, except the first two. We consider ourselves to be serious
> supporters of traditional jazz.
> We are giving the 2007 Jubilee a pass. Future Jubilees will be similarly
> 'passed' if the management of the affair continues on what appears to be its
> current course in the matter of band selection.
> On the bright side, there are still three West Coast Festivals where
> traditionalists can get a proper 'fix', but we will save that subject for
> another day."
> John Doyle
> Windsor California
> Editor Don Jones sent a great response as an Editor's note, which is too
> long to post here except for the first paragraph which said; "I hope you
> realize that passing up the Sacramento Jazz Jubilee will do nothing to
> improve what you feel is lacking in their band selection process."
> Don went on to suggest that these fans put their money where their mouths
> are and financially sponsor their favorite bands, etc.
> As for me, just what the hell is this fan's problem? No trad at Sacto? He
> must have been totally uninformed. He talks generally, but says nothing
> about which bands he felt were slighted, or which bands will appear at the
> "three festivals" that did not appear at Sacramento. Just what does this fan
> expect from a paltry expenditure of an all events badge?
> Max Kaminsky said over a half century ago that one of the big problems with
> trad jazz was the fans themselves who become self-proclaimed experts and
> believe that jazz should revolve around their expertise. By telling the
> musicians what jazz is or isn't, who plays it or not, what instruments
> should be used, and then end up demanding total silence, etc . . . the fans
> are killing it.
> IMO, Mr. Doyle's rant is totally bogus. Sacramento Jubilee (as well as other
> festivals) was ready to fold because of prior mismanagement. The current
> management rescued it. Jill Harper, Bob Ringwald and everyone else involved
> with producing it should be cheered and thanked rather than subject to Mr.
> Doyle's self important rant. Who needs fans like that?
> Fans like him might do us all a favor by staying home and listening to
> records. Make way for the new audience.
> Steve Barbone
> To unsubscribe or change your e-mail preferences for the Dixieland Jazz Mailing list, or to find the online archives, pleas visit:
> Dixielandjazz mailing list
> Dixielandjazz at ml.islandnet.com
More information about the Dixielandjazz