[Dixielandjazz] Getting Serious for a minute

Harold Smith s3856lpa at webtv.net
Mon Sep 18 18:26:55 PDT 2006


Now why would anyone gripe about some arrangement written in Gb.  The cornet guy only has to play in 4 flats.  Not really an ordeal, but challenging if you're used to playing everything in F or Bb.

What is really arduous are those adventurous song writers who take you into uncharted waters, like that sneaky Ray Noble who wrote a tune in Bb, and suddenly hits you with a bridge that starts off with a C# min. 9th (F# 13th), to a B, and takes you down full step by full step back to the home key.  Someone with a heart would have left the song in something easily playable.  Like, maybe "Cherokee"?

Regards.
Harold





More information about the Dixielandjazz mailing list