[Dixielandjazz] "Biographical Guide to the Great Jazz and Pop Singers" Reviewed

Robert Ringwald rsr at ringwald.com
Fri Jun 3 10:46:46 PDT 2011

"Biographical Guide to the Great Jazz and Pop Singers" reviewed
'Delighted with the Results'
A guide to singers and songs that's encyclopedic in its details
by Robert Leiter
Jewish Exponent (Philadelphia), June 1, 2011
Pantheon Books has given "A Biographical Guide to the Great Jazz and Pop Singers"
by Will Friedwald a beautiful outer design, with a simple but effective cover that
uses art and graphics with consummate skill. Your interest is peaked. But then you
open the book and your heart sinks. This really is just a guide after all, with an
alphabetical listing like so many others, the text laid out in two tight columns
per page using small-sized type. Something that started out so grandly a few moments
before winds up looking in reality just like a Leonard Maltin guide to the movies.
But then you start reading and all misgivings melt away. Guides can sometimes be
informative, sometimes fun to read, sometimes vapid and annoying, but rarely do they
have the depth and comprehensiveness that Friedwald has brought to his subject (and
when you check out his photo and see how young he is, and all he's already accomplished,
you'll be astounded that anyone that age could have possibly learned so much, even
if all he did was concentrate on a single subject, which he hasn't). The point size
of the type may be minute, but Friedwald's prose bursts with detail and insights
unlike any other such guide you might choose to consult.
Because his focus is on the singers, there are only a handful of Jewish performers
here (the expected ones -- Al Jolson, Sophie Tucker, Eddie Cantor, Mel Torme, Eydie
Gorme, Bob Dylan). But Jews are everywhere throughout this book -- generally populating
the background -- because a great deal of what these singers performed was written
by Jews, especially if we're talking about the golden age of popular songwriting.
Take the appropriately lengthy entry on Ella Fitzgerald. Friedwald addresses -- then
clears away -- the criticism that the great Ella, who was proverbially known as the
First Lady of Song, didn't have any idea about what she was singing, that she was
never cued into the meaning of the lyrics. The author finds this critique, which,
at a certain time had wide currency, ridiculous, unworthy of taking seriously. Then
he writes:
"Though she was never as textually specific as [Frank] Sinatra nor as 'sad' as [Billie]
Holiday, Fitzgerald was always emotionally true to whatever she was singing: She
could make you walk on air with a happy song and want to walk on razor blades on
a downer. She sang the lyrics of Lorenz Hart, Oscar Hammerstein, Ira Gershwin, Johnny
Mercer, Sammy Cahn, Johnny Burke, and any other Tin Pan Alley poet as well as anybody
else in the canon of great jazz and pop singers, and there's no indication that any
of these gentlemen was anything but delighted with the result."
Or you can go the entry on Sarah Vaughan, who some would say was the only singer
who gave Ella a real run for her money in terms of "first-lady" status. Friedwald
looks into Vaughan's "church roots," which the author says are apparent in everything
she ever did -- and then the majority of the jazz and pop songs he cites were written
by Jews.
Decoration of the Highest Sort
Vaughan's "melismas [i.e., a succession of different notes sung upon a single syllable]
and other decorations of her singing have much in common with the gospel style. Martin
Williams once referred to this aspect of her artistry as 'an opera singer without
an opera.' He might just as easily have called her a gospel singer without a church
-- though hardly without a prayer. When she sings 'Maria' from 'West Side Story'
(on 'You're Mine You'), it's my idea of angels singing the 'Ave Maria.' It's instructive
to remember that, in the first half of the 20th century, traditional black spirituals
were regarded as the first American 'art' music, and that concert singers both black
and white in the '20s and '30s -- when Vaughan was growing up -- were almost as likely
to include 'Motherless Child' as they were to sing Schubert lieder.
"And although Vaughan holds one 'Maria' for more measures than any other human being
could count, let alone sing, the performance is more than operatic -- it's downright
spiritual. Lines like 'The most beautiful sound I ever heard' take on religious overtones,
and her reiteration of the word 'Maria' (itself a distinctly Catholic reference)
assumes the quality of a chant. When she gets to the line 'Say it soft/And it's almost
like praying,' she takes lyricist Stephen Sondheim at his word, employing the aspect
of her artistry that's usually reserved for ecumenical works like 'The Lord's Prayer.'
(The way she expresses the same idea in a different song reveals an entirely different
attitude. The line 'I started praying' occurs in 'Moonglow' and also on 'You're Mine
You,' but there the implications are far less ecumenical. As with other tracks on
the album, such as the Cy Coleman hits 'The Best Is Yet to Come' and 'Witchcraft,'
the mood on 'Moonglow' is light and swinging.) 'Send in the Clowns,' the super-spectacular
set piece of her final decade, is also sung like a hymn, overdecorated to the hilt
with melismas and flourishes galore."
In this book, which runs to 800 tightly packed pages, Friedwald even makes space
for a small section on "Singing Songwriters," among them one of my favorites, Harold
Arlen, who was born Hyman Arluck, the son of a cantor.
Writes the author: "Much has been made (by myself, certainly) of Harold Arlen's involvement
with the world of jazz, perhaps a little too much. He and Gershwin were the only
members of the Broadway Big Six who were capable enough instrumentalists to support
themselves as musicians before their ASCAP royalties began coming in. The comparison
with Gershwin is revealing: The older man came up through the world of songwriters
and song publishers, while Arlen entered the music industry by means of the dance
bands, which at the time were very close to -- and often indistinguishable from --
hot jazz. Both men approved of and encouraged the use of their music in the jazz
community: Gershwin was flattered when, even during his lifetime, jazzmen found endless
new uses for his chord sequences (notably 'I Got Rhythm'). On the other hand, they
didn't have to rewrite Arlen's melodies: Just as Arlen wrote them they sounded jazzy
I've quoted at length to give some sense of what Friedwald has accomplished here,
but in reality what I've cited amounts to only a fraction of the erudition on display
throughout these pages. And for those who can't get enough of this lore, Friedwald
writes in his introduction that he's hoping that this book will be the first of many
editions. "It's a dream of mine to revisit and update it every six or seven years
-- whatever the traffic will allow -- and that... it can be something of a perennial.
I hope to keep revising it, to update the sections on those artists who are still
alive and active and to rediscover vintage performers who may have fallen through
the cracks the first time around."
Fans of great singing should make their way to this work in droves. Not only will
they be entertained, but perhaps their sheer numbers will convince Pantheon that
Friedwald's wish should become a reality whenever the author suggests.

--Bob Ringwald
Fulton Street Jazz Band
530/ 642-9551 Office
916/ 806-9551 Cell
Amateur (Ham) Radio K6YBV

"If a politician found he had cannibals among his constituents, he would
promise them missionaries for dinner."
H. L. Mencken 1880-1956

More information about the Dixielandjazz mailing list