[Dixielandjazz] Sibellius or Finale or Encore?

[Mike C.]

The differences between Finale and Sibelius vary from person to person. 
Both are really good programs that are used extensively by compsers 
worldwide. They tend to work better on mac computers than on the pc. 
Finale has certain features that seem to only work on mac.



Robert Reck wrote:
> Sibelius will not directly import Encore files.  
>  
> I had an ancient DOS program called Music Printer Plus.  I have gotten it to run (somewhat) in a DOS window on my XP machine.  I saved all the files as MIDI files and opened the midi files in Sibelius.  There was still some work to do, but not nearly so much as starting all over.
>  
> Sibelius and Finale both have a "scanner" feature, but I am not sure how well it works.  I have never tried it and I have not heard good things about it.
>  
> I have a good friend who paid for his house renovation and his new car by writing music for marching bands.  He switched from Encore to Sibelius about 18 mo. ago and is very happy.  Note entry is a snap in Sibelius.  My favorite is step time.  One hand on the midi keyboard and one hand on the number pad switching note/rest values.
>  
> Sibelius recently added a feature whereby the parts are a part of the score.  Edit the score and the parts change, edit the part and the score changes.  OTOH, things can be added to the score that do not appear on the parts and vice-versa.  You do not have to extract parts or keep track of which set of parts go with the current version of the score.  This is a wonderful idea, but I have not tried the upgrade yet.  I was working on an original composition for jazz band last summer and the parts/score thing about drove me nuts.  (If you are curious about the final result you can see it at my Sibeliusmusic page.  The link is below my signature. The chart is called "Almost Summer".  The changes should give away the title.  The lead sheet is free, BTW).
>  
> I have never used Finale and cannot contrast the two programs.
> 
> Rob Reck
> Tulsa Klezmer Band
> 
> Ministry of Jazz <jazzmin at actcom.net.il> wrote:
> Shalom Jazz fans,
> 
> I still need a bit of help on the question of which direction to go in my
> next music composition software upgrade. Encore 4.2 indeed does not work on
> my new rig with Win XP. If I buy the new Encore for $400, I basically get
> the same capabilities I already had, but it works in XP. I have tried Finale
> before, but only a scaled down trial version, and I didn't like it. That was
> about 4 years ago. Never tried Sibellius.
> 
> Questions:
> 
> 1. I have my entire Dr Jazz Band repertoire in Encore files as well as
> other material I use to teach. Do either of the other two read Encore files?
> 
> 2. What significant improvements might there be in Sibellius or Finale over
> Encore?
> 
> 3. Can any of them save files to PDF or a graphics format that can be
> emailed to players?
> 
> 4. Is there any place to buy any of these programs at a significant savings
> off the retail price?
> 
> Thank you for any help anyone can offer from this great list.
> 
> Elazar
> Dr. Jazz Dixieland Band
> Tekiya Trumpet Ensemble
> Jerusalem, Israel
> www.israel.net/ministry-of-jazz
> +972-2-679-2537
> _______________________________________________
> Dixielandjazz mailing http://ml.islandnet.com/mailman/listinfo/dixielandjazz
> 
> 
> Rob Reck
> reckeuph at sbcglobal.net
> http://members.sibeliusmusic.com/robreck
> _______________________________________________
> Dixielandjazz mailing list
> Dixielandjazz at ml.islandnet.com
> http://ml.islandnet.com/mailman/listinfo/dixielandjazz
> 
> 
> 


-- 
"80 percent of Republicans are just Democrats who don't know what's
going on. The only difference is there is a huge informational deficit
in the red states."

-Robert F. Kennedy Jr (1954- )